#1 - Xander's Strawberry/Lime
#2 - Dawn's a Centaur! Root Beer
#3 - Willow's Green Apple Witch's Brew
#4 - Twilight's Old Moon Orange & Cream
#5 - Buffy's Blue Bubblegum
#6 - Giles's Grape Potion
Bitsy's review list in order of preference:
#1 - Giles's Grape Potion
#2 - Dawn's a Centaur! Root Beer
#3 - Willow's Green Apple Witch's Brew
#4 - Xander's Strawberry/Lime
#5 - Twilight's Old Moon Orange & Cream
#6 - Buffy's Blue Bubblegum
As you can see, our opinions/favorites differed quite a bit but eh, to each his own. Have you sampled the ye olde Jones? What did you think?